Skin & Regeneration
Why Skin Pigmentation Changes Cannot Be Attributed to One Cause by Appearance
A change in skin color does not identify one diagnosis. Several conditions can overlap in color, shape, and location, and more than one can be present. Sun exposure, hormonal changes, inherited factors, and skin injury are possible contributors; color alone cannot show which applies. A patch resembling melasma still needs assessment, and earlier inflammation or injury relevant to post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation may be invisible in a photograph. Pigment depth can also require examination with a Wood lamp or, in some cases, a skin biopsy. Online information cannot confirm a diagnosis from a photograph or determine an appropriate care plan.
- Similar color, shape, and location can occur in several conditions at once.
- Ultraviolet light, hormones, inherited factors, and skin injury can contribute to darkening.
- A familiar melasma-like distribution or shade is not confirmation of melasma.
- Brown patches that look similar may have developed through different processes.
- Online information can explain possible causes and what a clinician may assess, but it cannot confirm a diagnosis from a photograph or determine an appropriate care plan.
Melasma, post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation (PIH), or freckles may come to mind when brown or gray-brown patches appear on the face. PIH means darkening that follows inflammation or injury. These possibilities are not interchangeable diagnoses, and a color difference from nearby skin may reflect more than one condition.
Darkening has several possible backgrounds
The Korean Dermatological Association lists ultraviolet exposure, hormonal changes with pregnancy or oral contraceptives, inherited factors, and some medications in its melasma information. Cleveland Clinic lists skin injury, sun damage, medication, hormonal changes, and various health conditions as possible causes of hyperpigmentation. Color cannot identify which contributor applies to a particular person.[1,2,7]
A similar distribution and color do not confirm melasma
Melasma can appear as brown or gray-brown patches, mainly on exposed facial skin. The Korean Dermatological Association and Asan Medical Center discuss possible roles for ultraviolet light, hormones, and inherited susceptibility. The association also calls for distinguishing melasma from other causes of facial hyperpigmentation. Resembling a common melasma pattern does not settle the diagnosis.[1–3]
Similar brown patches can develop differently
Asan Medical Center notes that a lesion thought to be melasma may instead be a nevus of Ota, a type of pigmented skin mark, freckles, or another pigmented spot. These conditions can also coexist. DermNet lists PIH, solar lentigines (spots associated with sun exposure), freckles, and drug-induced pigmentation among conditions that can resemble melasma. Their similar appearance does not mean they share a cause.[4,5]
Why earlier inflammation or injury matters
DermNet and the review by Davis and Callender describe PIH after conditions or injuries such as acne, dermatitis, infection, burns, and wounds. That is why a clinician asks what happened before the discoloration and whether there was inflammation at the same site. That history may not be visible in one photograph.[6,8]
Appearance alone cannot determine pigment depth
The Korean Dermatological Association describes using a Wood lamp, an examination light, when assessing the layer containing melasma pigment. DermNet says PIH assessment combines a careful history with skin examination and may sometimes require a biopsy. Cleveland Clinic also describes questions about when darkening began and which medicines are being taken. Further examination or tests depend on the suspected cause.[1,2,6,7]
Online information can help explain possible causes and what a clinician may investigate. It should not be used to label a photographed change as melasma, freckles, or PIH and select care accordingly. If the cause is uncertain or the discoloration is concerning, seek assessment that brings the history and examination together.
Treatment itself can worsen pigment changes. DermNet warns that peels and lasers may worsen melasma or cause PIH, and that physical treatments can aggravate PIH through epidermal injury. DermNet also describes a high risk of melasma relapse and of the condition becoming harder to treat after some energy procedures.[5] The Davis and Callender review cautions against treatment-related irritation that can worsen PIH. Cleveland Clinic advises medical assessment when affected skin is red, hot, itchy, painful, or leaking blood, pus, or another substance.[5–8]
References
- Korean Dermatological Association, “기미” (in Korean). https://www.derma.or.kr/new/general/disease.php?mod=document&uid=3378
- Korean Dermatological Association, “기미(Melasma)” (in Korean). https://www.derma.or.kr/new/general/disease.php?mod=document&uid=1022
- Asan Medical Center, “기미” (in Korean). https://www.amc.seoul.kr/asan/healthinfo/disease/diseaseDetail.do?contentId=32610&tabIndex=0
- Asan Medical Center, “기미 치료와 예방” (in Korean). https://news.amc.seoul.kr/news/con/detail.do?cntId=7749
- DermNet, “Melasma (facial pigmentation).” https://dermnetnz.org/topics/melasma
- DermNet, “Postinflammatory hyperpigmentation.” https://dermnetnz.org/topics/postinflammatory-hyperpigmentation
- Cleveland Clinic, “Hyperpigmentation.” https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/21885-hyperpigmentation
- Davis EC, Callender VD. “Postinflammatory Hyperpigmentation: A Review of the Epidemiology, Clinical Features, and Treatment Options in Skin of Color.” The Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic Dermatology. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2921758/
Frequently asked questions
Do matching patches on both cheeks establish melasma?
That distribution can occur in melasma, but it cannot confirm it. Other pigmentary conditions may resemble it or coexist with it.
Is every brown mark where acne occurred post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation?
Earlier inflammation is an important clue, but other pigment changes at the same site still need consideration. A clinician assesses the history together with the current skin findings.
Does a brown color mean the pigment is near the surface?
Color alone cannot determine pigment depth. The Korean Dermatological Association describes using an examination tool such as a Wood lamp to help assess the layer containing pigment.
Does darkening after sun exposure identify the cause?
Ultraviolet light can influence several pigmentary conditions, including melasma and post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation. A connection with sun exposure alone cannot identify which condition is present.